Film Review: "Being Heumann"
From the Oscar-winning director of CODA, Ruth Madeley stars as activist Judy Heumann in this retelling of her twenty-one day sit-in protest that earned widespread accomodations for Americans with disabilities in 1977.
Chloe Zhao used her Best Picture-winning blank check to make Hamnet in a way that only she could. Christopher Nolan parlayed Oppenheimer's success into The Odyssey, which became a two-billion dollar hit. The Daniels are making a Power Rangers homage that's due to hit theaters next year, and Sean Baker is taking a journey to Italy with Vera Gemma using the money that Warner Bros. Clockwork just made off of The Devils. So, what has Sian Heder done in the five years since CODA?
Shortly after Oscar Sunday in 2022, Heder was announced to be in development on The Impossible Us, a high-concept romantic comedy that was never heard of again after the announcement. A year later, Heder was in the trades again, now attached to The Blue Afternoon That Lasted Forever. This science-fiction drama would have seen Heder move to Paramount Pictures, away of her homefield Apple Studios. Apple acquired CODA after it's Sundance premiere, was set to host The Impossible Us, and eventually distributed Heder's Being Heumann this year. But, before Heder was even circling Being Heumann, she was in the trades—yet again—attached to Tomorrow, Tomorrow and Tomorrow, a romantic drama set for Fall 2027 from Paramount Pictures, although unlikely to see the light now given the studio's recent acquisition of Warner Bros. and subsequent restructuring. All this to say, when Sian Heder could not make anything else—not afforded the same artistic cache as her Best Picture-winning peers—she backed into a corner and made Being Heumann...

...And Being Heumann is a film that feels made out of obligation, not passion. CODA meets its performers on their own level, adapting its filmic language to the necessities of communicating every line of dialogue with consideration for both ASL and on-screen captions. Heder does not get the credit she deserves for the delicate hand she directed that film with, and was rudely snubbed from a Best Director nomination from the Academy's directing branch. If it weren't for the similar casting approach at the front of the film's marketing campaign, you might not even know Heder directed Being Heumann, as this film bares no resemblance to the direction of CODA. Being Heumann's cinematography is crass, awkward, and never settles into itself. It looks too digital for a period piece, and is shot too casually for a prestige "true story" drama. The blocking is awkward and uncomfortable in a way that CODA, and even Heder's debut film Tallulah were not. The screenplay is equally unconfident. Every scene that you'd wish were longer ends just when it becomes interesting, and all of the scenes that go down like shoe leather overstay their welcome. The film spends its first half slowly building and fleshing out a romantic interest for Judy, teasing the consummation of their love and the complex implications of that for a disabled person, only to cut away as soon as he finally touches her for the first time. The same goes for a scene later into the film when the San Francisco Police Department is intimidating the protestors by waking them up in the middle of the night with a random search, just as tensions hit their apex, the film yada-yada-yada's along.
The story at the center of Being Heumann is a noble one worth telling to a new audience, but as it is, watching the film is a chore. Most folks would be better, and learn just as much, by watching the Drunk History "Civil Rights" episode that retells the same story in a more lively, succinct fashion.
★★★
Kenna Wong Ghaill